Are you a homeschool parent who got excited about Charlotte Mason homeschool history — all those living books, all that rich engagement — and then watched it collapse under the weight of real life? You’re not alone. I did the deep dive, fell in love with the idea of living books, and then reality (a kid with dyslexia, a second learner joining the mix, and a curriculum that wasn’t actually open-and-go) forced me to rebuild the whole thing.
Why Charlotte Mason Homeschool History Appealed to Us in the First Place
The idea of living books spoke to my soul when I first started researching Charlotte Mason. I pictured reading all day with my kids instead of grinding through a dry textbook. My oldest loved listening to stories — his favorite device is still his Yoto Mini — and the idea of surrounding my kids with interesting living books instead of a textbook really appealed to all of them.
This post contains an Amazon affiliate link. I may earn a small commission on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I know living books work, too, because when I think back on my own history education, the time periods I actually remember are attached to a book I read, not a chapter I memorized for a test.
Where the Standard CM Approach Broke Down
Here’s where it gets tricky: in the Charlotte Mason world, kids are usually expected to transition into mostly independent learning by third or fourth grade — with guidance, but independent enough that you can shift your attention to your younger kids. Well, you know what they say about well-laid plans.
Enter dyslexia. My son didn’t reach that independence by third or fourth grade, because dyslexia affects how the brain processes written words and sounds. So as he climbed in grades, so did the amount of reading I was doing with him — out loud, every subject. Then I added a second learner into the homeschool mix. As much as I love reading with my kids, one-on-one for every subject just wasn’t sustainable anymore. I needed a way to keep the education I wanted for them, accommodate my son, and lighten my own load as the teacher.
How I Modified Our Charlotte Mason Homeschool History Plan
If you’ve watched any of my videos, you know my brain works in systems — I tweak things until they’re efficient. So in true ADHD fashion, I hyperfocused for a long time and built a whole system for this year’s early modern history (1600s–1850s). Here’s what our modified Charlotte Mason homeschool history plan actually looks like now, for my visual, hands-on learners with dyslexia and dysgraphia in the mix.
BiblioPlan as Our Spine
We use BiblioPlan history as our spine — the textbook, the audio that goes with it, and the map work. A couple of years ago I made the rule that I wasn’t buying any history curriculum without an audio component, because we’re a busy family with a lot of appointments, and audio lets us put car time to good use. My visual learners follow along in the textbook while it’s reading, and if a kid isn’t at reading level yet, just looking at the pictures while they listen still does a lot of work.
For map work, my sixth grader and third grader each do their own sheet at the table, usually alongside that week’s lesson. My third grader labels the main bodies of water and countries. My sixth grader does the whole sheet and applies more of what we’re learning through the prompts. He also has dysgraphia, so depending on his energy that day, we sometimes take turns writing.
Layering In Multi-Sensory Supplementation
Listening to the BiblioPlan audio wasn’t enough on its own for my visual and hands-on learners, and supplementing it myself every week was eating up huge amounts of my planning time. So I built an open-and-go main guide for my Charlotte Mason homeschool history around five categories:
Physical books — I picked well-illustrated living books and DK informational books and assigned them to the weeks they fit best, rather than forcing a book into every single week (I tried that in the past — it wasn’t sustainable). They’re set out unschooling-style for the kids to grab during free time or independent reading.
Audiobooks — I favorite era-appropriate titles on Hoopla through our local library and play them in the car after we’ve finished that week’s history audio. The guide lists them roughly in chronological order, but we’re not strict about it.
YouTube videos — I curate about an hour’s worth per week, hyperlinked under each week for easy access, plus a master playlist.
Friday movies — a movie that ties to what we’re studying, loosely or directly. It doesn’t happen every week, but when we’re home, it’s a nice slow-down after a busy week.
Journaling — a complementary journal guide with weekly pages, plus discussion questions under the audiobooks and movies covering literary elements: setting, author, perspective, what we think will happen next. It makes the listening less passive, and it doubles as language arts.
What a Real Week Looks Like for Modified Charlotte Mason Homeschool History
Monday: Map work and discuss journal idea pages, since we usually have more time.
Tuesday: History audio in the car while they follow along in the textbook (or color, once they’re done).
Wednesday/Thursday: Audiobooks in the car.
Journaling: Happens during independent school time throughout the week.
The whole thing is mapped out across 34 weeks to match the BiblioPlan pacing, plus a bonus week 35 for reflection — a chance for the kids to look back at their journals and notice what surprised them or how far their skills came that year.
Still Charlotte Mason Underneath — Just Teacher-Light
This is still Charlotte Mason at its core: living books, real engagement with ideas, short lessons. It’s just teacher-light now, and it flexes across multiple kids learning from the same spine at different depths — this year that’s a kindergartener, a third grader, and a sixth grader. If reading isn’t working for a kid that day, they have audio, video, or hands-on journaling to tune into instead.
Grab the Guides I Built
I want to be upfront: this isn’t a replacement for BiblioPlan, and it isn’t affiliated with them. It’s a companion I built because I needed it — though there’s enough supplementation layered in that you could use it on its own if that’s what works for your family. If you’re covering early modern history (1600s–1850s) this year, you can grab what I made here:
Disclosure: These guides are original resources I created to pair with BiblioPlan. I am not affiliated with or sponsored by BiblioPlan.
Related Reading
If you’re wondering whether Charlotte Mason is even the right fit for a neurodivergent learner, start with Charlotte Mason Homeschooling: Helpful or Harmful for Neurodivergent Learners? For the bigger picture of what we’re using across every subject this year, see our full homeschool curriculum lineup. And if you want to see how history fits into our actual weekly rhythm, check out our realistic homeschool schedule for ADHD, autism, and dyslexia.
What’s Next
Coming up, I’m digging into how we tackle the journaling piece specifically, how language arts gets folded into other subjects instead of taught in isolation, and how I organize our whole school year so it doesn’t fall apart by October. Subscribe on YouTube or follow along here so you don’t miss it.
FAQ
Is this the same thing as BiblioPlan?
No. BiblioPlan is the textbook, audio, and map work we use as our spine. My Main Guide and Journal Guide are companion resources I built to add the visual, hands-on, and journaling layers our Charlotte Mason homeschool history plan needed — they aren’t made or endorsed by BiblioPlan.
What ages does this work for?
We’re using it with a kindergartener, a third grader, and a sixth grader, all from the same spine at different depths. The framework flexes easily — you adjust how much of the map work, journaling, or independent reading each kid takes on. My kindergartener is more of a tag-along right now — she’s involved as much as her attention span allows that day. If I only had a kindergartener, I’d actually wait until first grade to start.
Do I need both guides, or just one?
It depends on your needs. If you want a fully immersive, hands-on history experience, get both. If you want something open-and-go but don’t plan on journaling, the Main Guide alone covers you. If you’re really just looking for journaling support, grab the Journal Guide.
Leave a Reply